X-ray inspection is highly effective, but it may be quietly damaging your chips.
In the electronics manufacturing industry, X-ray inspection is almost like having 'X-ray vision.' After a Ball Grid Array (BGA) or Flip Chip is soldered onto a circuit board, the solder joints hidden beneath the package—completely invisible to the naked eye—can only be checked for issues like cold solder joints or voids using X-ray imaging. X-ray inspection is efficient, non-destructive, and doesn’t require disassembly, making it a standard tool for quality verification in surface mount technology.
However, problems soon followed:X-rays are essentially ionizing radiation. While they are used to 'scan' chips, is there a risk that the X-rays could actually damage the chips themselves during the process?This is exactly what Micron's technical note (TN-00-32) aims to remind all professionals about.
1. Overlooked Risks: From 'Never Breaks' to 'Quietly Deteriorating'
Device manufacturers usually reassure users by saying that the dose from standard X-ray inspections is very low and won’t cause devices to fail directly. That’s true, but it’s only half the story.
What we really need to be wary of is not being 'eliminated' on the spot, but rather...Latent damage—The device passes all tests on site and appears to function normally, but some of its critical parameters have already been pushed to their extreme limits. Once it enters the actual working environment, fluctuations in temperature or voltage can trigger delayed failures. Multiple published studies have pointed out that even when the radiation dose level does not cause obvious hard failures, it can still pose risks to irradiated devices. Moreover, the 'threshold' for this kind of degradation is difficult to define. In other words,You might pass the test today, but you could fail when you actually use it tomorrow.That's usually how it happens.
However, it's important to be objective: only a small portion of samples are actually affected. Most devices have enough margin in key or sensitive parameters to offset this risk. So there's no need to panic, but you should definitely stay aware and take preventive measures.
2. How Damage Occurs: Leakage Current and DRAM 'Memory Loss'
In a typical X-ray inspection system, the devices are exposed to a dose of approximately100–1000 rad (Si)This low-dose range. The damage caused by this level of radiation mainly manifests asIncreased leakage currentwhich in turn affects a series of key parameters.
Among them, DRAM'sStatic Refresh Time (tREF)It is one of the most vulnerable links. DRAM relies on the tiny charge stored in capacitors to represent 0 and 1, and the so-called 'tail bits' are precisely the weakest group of storage cells. Once exposed to X-rays, the charge can leak out through various mechanisms, including:Ground fault in the junction areaandGate-Induced Drain Leakage (GIDL)These are the two most critical pathways under low-dose ionizing radiation. The result is that the refresh time for these weakest units will degrade beyond the specifications listed in the datasheet, causing the chip to 'forget' and make errors when it needs to retain data for extended periods.
3. How to Minimize Harm: 5 Practical Tips
The good news is that it’s entirely possible to reduce the radiation dose absorbed by the device through manufacturing techniques, without compromising the quality of X-ray imaging. The technical note provides several recommended measures worth following:
Keep the exposure dose at 100 rad (Si) or lower.——Reduce radiation at the source.
Increase the distance between the sample and the focal point of the radiation beam.Because the dose rate decreases inversely with the square of the distance, even a slight increase in distance causes the dose to drop sharply.
Integrating filters into X-ray systems—Let it absorb the X-ray energy that could potentially cause harm.
Minimize the time required for testing and validation as much as possible.The shorter the exposure, the less absorption.
Avoid repeated detectionIf you can avoid retaking the shot, do so to reduce the accumulated dose.
The core logic behind these five points can actually be summed up in one sentence:On the premise of obtaining clear images, minimize the amount of radiation the chip is exposed to as much as possible.
4. Final Thoughts
X-ray inspection is not abandoned simply because there are potential risks; it remains an irreplaceable part of the modern electronics manufacturing quality chain. A truly professional attitude is not about blindly accepting a manufacturer's assurance that 'everything is fine,' but rather about acknowledging the existence of risks, understanding the mechanisms of damage (such as increased leakage current leading to DRAM refresh degradation), and proactively implementing safeguards in the manufacturing process.
For engineers, remembering two keywords is enough:Potential damageandDosage controlBy controlling the dosage, the X-ray vision can be both clear and harmless.
Reference source: Micron Technology, Inc. "Technical Note TN-00-32: Effect of X-Ray Radiation on Integrated Circuits and Techniques to Minimize Damage" (Rev. A, 2015)
